Case file · File · Prove All Things
The Governor Left. The Archbishop Stayed.
“But prove all things; hold fast that which is good.” — 1 Thessalonians 5:21, Douay-Rheims
The case
In fifteen seventy-six, the plague hit Milan. The governor left the city. A lot of the rich left with him. The archbishop stayed.
The evidence
Every quotation below is printed in the words of the edition named under it. Nothing is paraphrased.
“I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd giveth his life for his sheep.”John 10:11 (Douay) — read it at the source
What’s established, and what isn’t
What the sources support, claim by claim — each one checked against the sources listed at the foot of this page:
- Plague in Milan 1576-77 ('plague of San Carlo')
- The Spanish governor (Marquis of Ayamonte) and many nobles left Milan
- Borromeo born 1538 (38 in 1576), from the wealthy Borromeo family
- He sold his goods and used the money for the sick and poor
- He visited the sick, gave Communion, heard confessions
- He led barefoot penitential processions with a rope around his neck carrying the Holy Nail relic
- Thousands died (about 17,000 in Milan)
- He died 3 November 1584, aged 46, not of plague
Where the record stops short:
- How many died in Milan is not settled. The figures in popular accounts are estimates, not counts, so this file says what the record says: thousands.
- Borromeo died in 1584, at forty-six, and not of the plague.
For your men’s group
- The governor left and the archbishop stayed. What would have made you leave?
- He sold what he owned and spent it on the sick. What do you own that your neighbours' trouble has never touched?
- Where is the place in your own town you have been avoiding, and who is in it?
Get the next case file every Sunday
One letter, free. The sources, every week, before anyone asks for them.
No card. Unsubscribe any time.
Every source
- Born 2 October 1538, noble family, nephew of Pius IV, visited plague houses and the St Gregory hospital, barefoot procession with a rope and the relic of the Holy Nail, died 3 November 1584 aged 46, gave much of his property to the poor
- 'Sold even his bed for their support'; 'ever by the sick and dying'; refused to leave Milan
- Plague inside the walls 11 August 1576; governor Marquis of Ayamonte withdrew to Vigevano; nobility fled
- John 10:11 Douay-Rheims wording
- Mignard Communion-to-the-plague-victims composition: de Poilly engraving, Wellcome Collection, public domain; painting date and holder unsettled
Found an error? [email protected] — errata corrected the day they’re found.
Drafted with AI assistance, founder-directed, and checked against the sources linked here. Our editorial standards.
← All case files · The Library · Next case: The Mass in AD 155